The Abhorrent Burton Sipp Strikes Again

The Thoroughbred Daily News ran a long piece yesterday on a horse named Post Facto landing at a kill pen earlier this month. The piece opens thus:

“Post Facto made his career debut on Aug 21, 2022…in a [$100+K] race at Del Mar. More than four years later, now eight [he’s actually six], he ran for the last time, lagging behind the field…in a $5,000 claimer on Oct. 27 of this year at Finger Lakes. Twelve days later, he wound up at the Southern Ohio Horse Ship Pen, whose owner admits that some horses that come into his possession wind up being sent to slaughter.”

Here are my highlights from the article:

“[Post Facto] was claimed for $12,500 on July 6, 2024 by [Tony] Lima Horse Racing, which sent him first to trainer Pablo Torres and later to Ilmar Loaiza. His form would continue to worsen and Lima and its trainers would continue to drop him in class. The Finger Lakes-based Loaiza was the trainer of record when he made what would be his final start, his second straight last-place performance.

“It was clear that his value as a racehorse was virtually nothing. So the connections had a decision to make. What to do with Post Facto? According to a West Virginia-based trainer named Burton Sipp, he bought the horse off of Lima and Loaiza for $1,000.

“That Sipp, 82, has emerged as a figure in a messy situation is not a surprise. He is among the most controversial trainers in the sport and has been barred from several racetracks. He has been dogged by persistent allegations that he has knowingly funneled horses into the slaughter pipeline.”

(Burton Sipp, for those who may not be familiar, is a despicable human being and is no stranger to our site.)

TDN quotes Marlene Murray, founder of a rescue:

“We have pulled Burton Sipp horses from feedlots in the past and so have other people. We have seen his horses before at feedlots. He’s been taking horses to Smokey Lane for a while, quite a few years. The bottom line is that these lower-end auctions are a haven for killer buyers and dealers. So when people take them to those kind of places, the horses are always at high risk of being bought by a dealer or killer buyer. Mountaineer is supposed to have a no-slaughter policy. And we know that Mountaineer knows that he takes horses there, but obviously they haven’t done anything about it.”

(For more on Mountaineer’s utter apathy regarding horses who race there and end up in the slaughter pipeline, read this.)

She adds: “The no-slaughter policies…look good on paper, but they do have to be enforced. A lot of the tracks don’t enforce them, for whatever reason. They’ll have a hearing with someone and they’ll bring in a bill of sale for a dollar and that will be good enough. Or they’ll say they can’t remember, they just can’t seem to remember who they gave the horse to or sold the horse to. I mean, that’s crazy. If they’re going to have no-slaughter policies…they need to enforce them at all racetracks.”

As for Sipp, his response to the TDN:

“I bought the horse for $1,000 and he wasn’t going to make it as a racehorse. The horse had some big ankles on him and I think we galloped him a couple of days. I paid $1,000 for him and he sold for $900 at Smokey Lane, so I lost $100, plus what it cost me to ship him and keep him for a few days…. I gambled on buying the horse. I didn’t see him until after I had purchased him. I didn’t think the horse was going to make it as a racehorse with his ankles the way they were. It was not a good situation. So I sold him as a riding horse and that’s how he was cataloged, as a riding horse and to have a second career.”

The writer, Bill Finley, then says something entirely untrue: “Having paid $1,000 for Post Facto, Sipp would have little incentive to send him to slaughter as horses are worth less than that when sold to the equine abattoirs in Canada and Mexico.” Sipp was obviously just trying to cut his losses here – recoup as much of the grand that he could.

The article goes on to say that three other Thoroughbreds landed at that auction with Post, with one, Crystal Water, having been raced just three days before the “bail notice” went up for the four on Nov 7. (Crystal came directly from Mountaineer.) A man named Brian Duggan “listed a ‘ship date’ of Nov. 13.” Duggan to TDN: “We buy and sell horses to sell them for a profit. That’s what we do. I mean, if they don’t want to buy them, they don’t have to. I mean, we buy ponies, we buy work horses, we’ll buy anything.”

Then, “When asked directly by the TDN if he would admit that horses that have come through his operation sometimes wound up in a slaughterhouse, his answer was simple: ‘Yeah. There’s only so many places to go with them. There’s only so much you can do with them, so many people that can feed them. And if they don’t feed them, they end up in very poor condition. In my opinion, I’d rather see one slaughtered than starve to death.'”

Duggan adds: “I’d rather see these horses wind up in good homes than wind up in the slaughter pipeline. We want to see them get good homes and we’re willing to work with any horse rescue operation. I don’t want to be perceived as the devil.” Hmm.

Lucinda Finley, who coordinated the bail payment (all four made it out): “[K]nowing Sipp’s history and reputation, I can’t fathom why anyone, any owner or trainer at any racetrack, would ever sell him a horse. I stand by that because even if he thought he could get a race or two out of the horse, what do you think he would have done after that?” Exactly.

And with Finger Lakes set to close shop for the year in five days, hundreds of horses could be at grave risk as owners look to dump their “losers.” Finley: “The New York Gaming Commission and Finger Lakes pat themselves on the back and they say ‘look at all we are doing.’ The truth is, their rules are toothless. The current rules do not address the realities. Look at what happened to Post Facto. The system is broken.”

Broken? It never even was.

(Here is the full TDN piece.)

Subscribe and Get Notified of New Posts

2 Comments

  1. Thanks to you, Patrick, the industry now feels compelled to report this and put their own spin on it. Otherwise, it would be business as usual, and no one would ever know.
    Now they need to address the problem of Mr Sipp. Until they do, I will do everything within my power to keep this front and center until his ass is out of the picture once and for all.

  2. Thoroughbred Daily News certainly did expose the dark reality of how much the racing industry people truly “love” their horses; actually, in fact, how much they don’t love their horses. Is there any person at TDN who honestly cares about the horses enough to rescue any of these ‘dumped into the slaughter pipeline’ horses that can no longer be raced or used for breeding?

    Hopefully, those individuals who may have been duped by the standard lies coming out of the racing industry public relations department will not be deceived into thinking anything the industry may say is true in order to justify their own involvement in gambling on the horses, for example.
    People who bet on racehorses need to know that their money supports all of this heinous cruelty to horses. A person has to be a cold-hearted sadist to do what is done to racehorses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *