New Casinos May Crush Much of NY Horseracing

What most NY citizens do not know, by design, is that Video Lottery Terminals (VLTs), or slots, directly subsidize the state’s racing industry. Here’s how it works: As a condition for securing VLT licenses, track owners are required to continue running horseraces, whether profitable or not. But more importantly, a sizable chunk of slots revenue is funneled into the racing industry – higher purses, breeding supplements. If not for this largess, much of NY racing, especially the harness variety, would have vanished by now. In general, racing can no longer subsist on product alone, as evidenced by declining handle and attendance.

Currently, 9 of the 11 NY racetracks are set up as racinos – racing plus VLT gaming. (Although Saratoga and Belmont are not racinos, they, being under the NYRA banner, still benefit from Aqueduct’s.) But with four brand-new full-service casinos on the horizon, the horse people are justifiably worried. Even though the law requires new casinos to continue subsidizing horsemen, any casino built on a non-racetrack site will be sending less than what is currently gifted. That, coupled with a virtual certainty that casinos (up to seven have been approved) will obliterate one-dimensional racinos, explains the hand-wringing.

(News that the owners of Saratoga Casino and Raceway are looking elsewhere to open a casino – Rensselaer County, Orange County – prompted this response from Betty Holt, executive director of Harness Horse Breeders of New York State (Times Union): “I hear a lot of people saying this is the beginning of the end for us.”)

At some point, the ball will be securely back in the Legislature’s court. Its two options: continue propping an increasingly irrelevant industry or act in accordance with one of our founding economic principles and allow the market to be what it will be. If the latter, the good bet is that all nine racino racetracks in NYS – the seven harness plus Aqueduct and Finger Lakes – will become but a memory. Imagine that.

Roulette_-_detail

5 Comments

Leave a Comment

  1. Patrick why wouldn’t the state just let racing die??? I am sure you know the reason but I didn’t read about it in this post.

    In 2011 the economic impact equine industries generated was aproxamatly $4.2 billion. Yes that is billion with a B !!! Oh and over 30,000 full time jobs. Horse racing and breeding of thoroughbred and standard bred horses is essential for agreculture of New York.

    My stats come from the New York Equine Industry Economic Impact Study. Done by the New York Horse Racing and Agreculture Alliance.

    • Yes, I’ve seen those numbers, but first, they come from a study commissioned by the horse people, and second, so what? Our economy requires adjustment. If people aren’t interested in horseracing in enough numbers to sustain it – and they aren’t – then it’s time for the equine industry to find a new product. That’s life in America.

      • So What?? 30,000 jobs. That’s What !! Well maybe 30,001, because what would YOU write about then?? You would be left with “Wayne County Cat Hit By Car”.
        Yes the study was done by “Horse People”. Anti-horse people are welcome to do their own…

  2. Those interested in preserving the status quo are those who benefit from it. Change is not easy but it happens anyway, AC 2

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.